How Mega-Journals are Revolutionizing Biomedical Publishing: The Good, the Bad, and the Transformative

A great and brief article from the super well respected John P.A. Ioannidis in JAMA on recently publishing trends. It’s a really quick read, but if you’ve got even less time we’ve got you below.

Have you heard of mega-journals? They are open-access peer-reviewed journals that publish a large number of articles and charge fees for article processing. In the biomedical field, these mega-journals are growing rapidly. In 2015, only 11 Scopus-indexed journals published more than 2000 biomedical full papers, but in 2022, there were 55 such journals publishing over 300,000 articles. While these mega-journals maintain respectable impact factors that attract authors seeking to publish their work, they may perpetuate a dysfunctional system of scientific evaluation and publication. However, some characteristics of these journals align with desirable scientific practices. For instance, they may offer opportunities to curb publication bias and allow the publication of results that traditional specialty journals may deem undesirable. They may also change medical and scientific publishing at large through indirect effects on other journals, creating competition at the journal and publisher levels.

To maximize the benefits of mega-journals, it is crucial that they adopt transparent research practices, publish rigorous data, safeguard against conflicts of interest, and secure editorial independence. It’s also essential for scientists, medical and research institutions, and funders to give credit to and reward journals and publishers that promote more transparent and rigorous research practices. Additionally, empirical studies are needed to compare the rigor of the peer-review process by traditional journals vs mega-journals. While the explosive growth of mega-journals may lead to the decline of some previously prestigious journals, what matters is whether journals that publish the majority of literature endorse and facilitate the best research practices.

But there’s more!

This Week in Public Health is a curated newsletter that gathers and groups together the latest publications from approximately 20 influential public health journals that were released within the past seven days. Our mission is to provide our readers with free access to the most up-to-date research and information in the field of public health. We believe that science should be a public good and that everyone should have access to the latest findings and breakthroughs in the field, regardless of their background or financial means. By carefully selecting and presenting the most relevant and impactful publications, we aim to help public health professionals and enthusiasts stay informed and engaged in the latest developments and trends in their area of expertise. With This Week in Public Health you can be confident that you are staying ahead of the curve and are equipped with the most recent knowledge and insights to improve the health and wellbeing of communities around the world